Mining is an activity that has raised significant environmental and social concerns, especially regarding its negative impacts on bird populations and their natural habitats — particularly in South America.

South America is known for its incredible biological diversity, and birds play a key role in the region’s ecosystems. The continent is home to a wide variety of bird species, including some of the most iconic in the world. Birdlife not only has intrinsic value, it also fulfils ecological functions, including many ecosystem services such as plant pollination, seed dispersal and pest control. In addition, birds attract birdwatching tourism, a rapidly expanding sector that generates economic resources and numerous jobs in all these countries. This growing industry provides an alternative in many local communities and often generates higher tax revenues than the (mostly illegal) mining sector.

The effects of mining on birdlife.
Depending on local interests, a wide range of conflicts has developed between mining and birds, which, on a large scale, can have a significant impact on habitats and bird populations.
The destruction of natural habitats, water pollution and air degradation, noise pollution and vibrations generated by mining operations are just some of the negative effects that can affect birds. Mining often involves the removal of large areas of forest, which provide essential habitats for many bird species. This leads to a loss of biodiversity and a decline in bird populations in these areas, as well as a deterrent effect on potential local developments related to birdwatching and nature tourism.

Indeed, several scientific studies have analysed the direct and indirect effects of mining on bird communities. The effects of mining on bird communities are manifold. First, habitat destruction can lead to the displacement of breeding populations due to the loss of nesting areas, resulting in a decline in the populations of certain species, but also affecting food sources and, worse still, bird migration corridors and breeding areas. Water and air pollution can affect food availability and access to clean water sources for birds. Some bird species are particularly sensitive to these changes and may disappear from affected areas.
One study shows that exposure to low levels of mercury can affect birds’ immune competence and even increase their susceptibility to infectious diseases. In addition, mining operations can disrupt birds’ behavioural patterns, such as breeding, courtship and migration. Noise and vibrations generated by heavy machinery and explosions can scare birds away and cause them to leave their traditional territories. This can disrupt the structure of bird communities and the functionality of ecosystems.

New forms of mining


However, the biodiversity of the Mancomunidad del Chocó Andino must coexist with 12 mining concessions covering more than 17,000 hectares. To date, six concessions are in preparation and would occupy at least 9,000 more hectares. The north-western sector of Quito, or Chocó Andino, is also rich in minerals. This is why there are currently twelve mining concessions in the territory. Two of them (Melinachangó – Santa Bárbara and Natural Resources) have exploration permits, but not exploitation permits, according to local residents.
However, there has been no proper community awareness process and, on the contrary, clashes have already broken out.
In the Intag Valley, two ecosystems meet: part of the Ecuadorian Chocó – a global priority conservation area – and the Tropical Andes – the most biologically rich hotspot on the planet.
In this vast valley in the province of Imbabura, in northern Ecuador, residents have been fighting the Ecuadorian state for nearly three decades to prevent mining.
Since 2011, they have focused their efforts on stopping the Llurimagua project in particular. Nine years later, they have succeeded: on 24 September 2020, a judge granted them an injunction and precautionary measures to protect nature.

Frogs: endangered species
The victory of the frogs is a victory for everyone, he declares. The lawsuit filed by biologist Andrea Terán claims that the mining industry in Llurimagua poses an imminent and serious threat to harlequin frogs (Atelopus longirostris and Etopoglostris) and the confused nurse frog (Etopoglossus confusus), both endangered species. The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List classifies the confused nurse frog as endangered, while the harlequin frog is still on the list of extinct species – because it was considered extinct until 2016 and has not yet been updated. Both species are highly vulnerable because they only exist in this location, and Terán believes it is thanks to these frogs that the judge ruled in favour of precautionary measures. “The victory of the frogs is a victory for everyone,” she says.
According to a study published in the Tropical Science Journal in 2018, the Intag Valley protects several endangered and critically endangered species. It is home to mammals, birds, amphibians and plants that are unique to the cloud forest and páramo ecosystem, including the spectacled bear, the Andean tapir, the black-chested tapir, the Tandayapa Andean toad and the spider monkey. All of these species were threatened by the mining industry in Llurimagua, but today, thanks to precautionary measures and conservation efforts, the situation could change.

The measures implemented
The Ecuadorian Constitutional Court has approved a request for a referendum on mining in the Chocó region. This consultation will include voters living in the metropolitan district of Quito. The Court’s decision respects the right of Quito’s inhabitants to decide the future of one of the most biodiverse areas on the planet, the Andean Chocó having been declared. This decision is a first triumph for thousands of people seeking to protect the Ecuadorian capital’s most important natural heritage.
A popular consultation aims to ban mining. Residents are proposing sustainable alternatives such as tourism, organic production and even carbon sequestration. Furthermore, the Ecuadorian constitution protects the rights of nature. The recent court ruling against a hydroelectric project that aimed to reduce the flow of the Alambi River by 90% has just been declared a matter of law on the basis of articles in the constitution. In short, the rights of the Alambi River, one of the most important rivers in the Andean Chocó region, which flows through the province of Pichincha, have been violated by the La Maravilla hydroelectric project.
The resolution was issued on Monday 29 May, during the first instance of a process promoted by the “Colectivo Río Alambi”, formed by residents of the parish of Nanegal, in Quito. The Ministry of Environment, Water and Ecological Transition must also initiate a process to declare the Alambi River a protected area, whose flow could have been reduced by 90% if the works planned as part of the hydroelectric project had been carried out. In addition, the 2020 environmental registry is revoked, obtained electronically via the system.
Things are moving forward, but far too slowly in the face of the frenzy to exploit our resources.